Amera RabeeFact Checked

Ergatta vs. WaterRower (2024): Which Rowing Machine is Right for You?

We compare Ergatta and WaterRower, two leading water resistance rowers. Discover which offers the best home workout experience, from connected features to design and storage options.

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; we may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links. You can learn more about our review process here.

Introduction

Overview of Rowing Machines

It is not rare nowadays to witness people owning a best rowing machine for home usage, as this equipment offers a challenging and complete workout for the entire body while incorporating elements of cardiovascular fitness and strength training. From the available choices, the most viable are Ergatta and WaterRower as these have water-resistant technology and thus are closely related to rowing in the water. This review will give a comparison of the two most favorite rowing machines in the market, so you can decide with ease when outfitting your home gym.

Importance of Rowing Machines in Home Gyms

Traditionally, rowing machines are considered to be very valuable because they provide a comprehensive workout regime. Not only do they work out leg muscles, but they also work out the muscular system of the abdomen and the arm wod; as a result, they are efficient instruments for enhancing fitness.

Also, rowing is not a very strenuous activity hence can be taken by anybody without health complications including people of all ages. The natural supply of resistance from water as seen in models like the Ergatta and WaterRower makes the rowing activity fun and demanding at the same time.

Key Takeaways

  • Comprehensive Workout Benefits: Both Ergatta and WaterRower provide a full-body workout that combines cardiovascular fitness with strength training.
  • High-Quality Construction and Aesthetics: Both machines are made from high-quality wood, with Ergatta crafted from cherry wood and WaterRower available in multiple wood options.
  • Distinct Technological Features: The Ergatta stands out with its 17.3” HD touchscreen and gamified workouts, offering an interactive and engaging rowing experience. In contrast, the WaterRower features the S4 Performance Monitor, focusing on simplicity and essential metric tracking without the need for subscriptions.
  • User-Friendly Design and Comfort: Both rowers are designed for ease of use and comfort, featuring ergonomic seats and handles. They also use water resistance to provide a smooth and natural rowing experience, which adjusts based on the user’s effort.
  • Assembly and Maintenance: Both rowers are easy to assemble, with options for professional installation. Maintenance requirements are minimal, primarily involving the water tank to prevent algae growth.

Quick Introduction of Ergatta vs WaterRower

Regarding their quality and design, both the Ergatta and WaterRower are considered to be among the best water rowing machines available in the market today. These machines are wooden and while they do work; they also give the home gym that touch of class.

Despite several similarities with each other, the application will differ in its primary parameters, technical and technological characteristics, and the perceived ease of use by the subject of this research, which will be unveiled in this review.

Ergatta vs WaterRower: What’s the Same?

  • Both give you a pump like you’re rowing on real water
  • Use special water wheel tech for resistance
  • Work your whole body, like a full gym circuit
  • Easy on the joints, good for recovery days
  • Built tough with real wood, like old school home gym equipment
  • Made in the USA, just like classic bodybuilding gear
  • Use American wood, keeping it home-grown
  • Water tank doesn’t need much maintenance, like a reliable lifting partner
  • Can be stored upright, making them best home gym equipment for limited space

Ergatta vs WaterRower: What’s Different?

  • WaterRower has a basic display for tracking your stats
  • No membership needed for WaterRower
  • Ergatta has game-style workouts if you pay monthly
  • WaterRower can handle 200 pounds more weight
  • Ergatta takes up a bit more floor space
  • Ergatta only comes in cherry wood
  • Ergatta costs over $1,000 more than WaterRower
  • Ergatta offers group challenges and competitions, like having a virtual training crew

Ergatta vs WaterRower Video Review

Ergatta vs WaterRower- How Are They Different? (A Detailed Comparison) (Video Credit: The Savvy Professor YouTube Channel)

Product Overview of Ergatta Vs WaterRower

Ergatta Rower

1. Key Features: The Ergatta Rower is designed to offer a unique and engaging workout experience. Its standout feature is the 17.3” HD touchscreen, which provides access to a variety of gamified workouts. The machine uses authentic water resistance, which adjusts naturally to the user’s intensity, providing a smooth and realistic rowing experience.

Made from locally Appalachian cherry wood, this smart rower is both durable and aesthetically pleasing. Read our Ergatta Rower Review for all details

2. Specifications

  • Weight: 105 lbs with water
  • Dimensions: 86” L x 23” W x 40” H
  • Display: 17.3” HD touchscreen
  • Bluetooth-enabled: Yes
  • Resistance Type: Water
  • Weight Capacity: 500 lbs
  • Max Inseam Length: 40”

3. Price and Financing Options: The Ergatta Rower is priced at $2,199, down from its original price of $2,499 during promotional periods. Financing options are available through Klarna and Affirm, starting as low as $68.90 per month, making it accessible to a wider range of customers.

The lcd screen of ergatta rower machine.Ergatta HD touchscreen (Image Credit: Ergatta official website)

4. Purchase Details and Membership Plans: It comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee by which you can try the rower in the comforts of your own home. Ergatta has a membership that enables a user to access workouts and all the game options available on the device. Membership is available every month and annually for a better price and is cheaper if you intend to use it for long-term purposes.

5. Assembly Process and Ease: The Ergatta Rower is designed for easy assembly, requiring only 30-45 minutes and a provided Allen key. Customers can also opt for professional assembly and installation, ensuring a hassle-free setup.

Water Rower

1. Key Features: The WaterRower is known for its handcrafted wood frame and quiet operation. It features the S4 Performance Monitor, which tracks essential metrics such as stroke rate, speed, time, and distance. Like the Ergatta, it uses water resistance to provide a smooth and natural rowing experience.

2. Specifications

  • Weight: 103.5 lbs with water
  • Dimensions: 82” L x 22” W x 20” H
  • Display: S4 Performance Monitor
  • Bluetooth-enabled: No
  • Resistance Type: Water
  • Weight Capacity: 700 lbs
  • Max Inseam Length: 38”

3. Price and Financing Options: The WaterRower is more affordable, priced at $1,099. Financing is available through Bread Pay, with competitive rates starting at 0% APR. This makes it an attractive option for those looking for a high-quality rower at a lower cost.

The S4 performance monitor of WaterRower machine.WaterRower S4 Performance Monitor (Image Credit: WaterRower official website)

4. Purchase Details: Customers can choose from a variety of wood frame options, including oak, making it easy to match the rower with their home decor. The WaterRower does not require a subscription for basic functionality, providing a cost-effective solution for users.

5. Assembly Process and Ease: The assembly process for the WaterRower is straightforward, similar to the Ergatta. Customers can also choose professional installation if preferred, ensuring the rower is set up correctly and ready for use.

Comparative Analysis of Ergatta Vs WaterRower

Design and Aesthetics

  • Material and Build Quality: They are both made of solid wood and this improves the durability as well as the special touch of the models. The seat of the Ergatta is made of cherry wood, which is darker and has a clear grain compared to WaterRower’s offering of three wood types for customers to select.
  • Footprint and Storage: The Ergatta Rower measures 86” L x 23” W x 40” H, slightly larger than the WaterRower, which measures 82” L x 22” W x 20” H. Despite the size difference, both rowers can be stored vertically, saving space in your home gym when not in use.
  • Weight and Dimensions: Both rowers are relatively lightweight, with the Ergatta weighing 105 lbs and the WaterRower weighing 103.5 lbs, making them easy to move and store.
The Waterrower machine durability testWaterrower machine durability test (Image Credit: WaterRower website)

Performance and Technology

  • Resistance Type and Levels: Both rowers use water resistance, providing a smooth and natural rowing experience with unlimited resistance levels. The resistance adjusts naturally based on the user’s effort, simulating the feel of rowing on water.
  • Display and Metrics Tracking: The Ergatta features a 17.3” HD touchscreen that displays advanced metrics and provides access to interactive workouts. In contrast, the WaterRower uses the S4 Performance Monitor, which tracks basic metrics such as stroke rate, speed, time, and distance.
  • Connectivity and Apps: The Ergatta comes with Bluetooth compatibility with other fitness apps; therefore, customers can monitor their workouts and interact with other fitness lovers. WaterRower is not Bluetooth compatible but it can be fitted with Ergatta’s touch panel and bracket which offer the same use.
  • Gamified Experience vs. Traditional Monitoring: The Ergatta stands out with its gamified workouts, including live races and team competitions, making the rowing experience more engaging and motivating. The WaterRower provides a more traditional rowing experience, focusing on simplicity and effectiveness without the need for subscriptions or additional features.
The wifi connectivity test of ergatta rower wifi connectivity test.Ergatta rower wifi connectivity test (Image Credit: Ergatta website).

User Experience

  • Detailed Customer Reviews and Feedback: The consumers are satisfied with the game-like exercises and the touch screen of the Ergatta. They appreciate its simplicity and almost noiseless functioning; the majority of the users like its build and efficiency as training equipment.
  • User Experience in Different Workouts (HIIT, Endurance, etc.): The Ergatta is excellent for high-intensity interval training at home (HIIT) and endurance workouts due to its interactive programming and gamified features. The WaterRower is suitable for all workout types, offering a straightforward and effective rowing experience.
  • Ease of Use and Comfort: Both rowers are designed for comfort, featuring ergonomic seats and handles. The water resistance system ensures a smooth and consistent rowing experience, reducing the risk of strain or injury.

Maintenance and Durability

  • Long-term Ownership Experience: Both the Ergatta and WaterRower are known for their durability and quality craftsmanship, ensuring they remain functional and attractive for years. Users report minimal issues with wear and tear, making them a reliable investment for home gyms.
  • Maintenance Requirements: Maintenance for both rowers is minimal, primarily involving the water tank. Users should occasionally add water purification tablets to prevent algae growth and check for any signs of wear on the components.
  • Durability of Materials and Components: The high-quality wood frames and robust construction of both rowers ensure they withstand regular use without compromising performance. Components such as the seat, handle, and water tank are built to last, providing a consistent and reliable rowing experience.
The foot rest pad of Ergatta .The Ergatta foot rest pad test (Image Credit: Ergatta website)

Policies and Support

Warranty and Return Policies

  • Ergatta Warranty and Return Policy: The Ergatta offers a 5-year warranty on the frame, 3 years on components, and 1 year on the touchscreen. The company provides a 30-day risk-free trial, allowing customers to return the rower if they are not satisfied, with Ergatta covering the return shipping costs.
  • WaterRower Warranty and Return Policy: The WaterRower comes with a 1-year limited warranty, which can be extended to 5 years on the frame and 3 years on components upon registration. Customers must contact customer service to authorize a return and are responsible for shipping fees.
  • Comparison and Customer Service Experience: Both companies offer solid customer service and support. Ergatta’s 30-day trial and comprehensive warranty provide peace of mind, while WaterRower’s extended warranty and straightforward return process ensure customer satisfaction.

Financing Options

  • Detailed Financing Options for Both Rowers: Ergatta offers financing through Klarna and Affirm, with plans starting as low as $68.90 per month. WaterRower offers financing through Bread Pay, with competitive rates starting at 0% APR.
  • Comparison of Plans and Interest Rates: Both rowers provide flexible financing options, making them accessible to a broader range of customers. Ergatta’s financing options are slightly more varied, while WaterRower’s competitive rates offer excellent value for money.

conclusion for Ergatta Vs WaterRowerConclusion

When it comes to the construction both the Ergatta and WaterRower possess excellent quality, water resistance, and beautiful wooden frames. The Ergatta is most unique for its actual workout and its interactive touch screen, while WaterRower is a simple machine, with no frills and no subscriptions.

The Ergatta is suitable for people who like interactive workouts and who like using technology as part of their exercise routine and use of features as motivators. The WaterRower does not possess any complex programs; therefore, it is suitable for people who want to get a quality rowing device with a concentration on good quality and long life.

Go for the Ergatta if you want solid tech, an engaging workout, and to pay for the software upgrade to get the full experience. Choose the WaterRower if you are fine with elegance, a relatively cheap price tag, and a conventional rower feel.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) for Ergatta Vs WaterRower

Q. Is WaterRower the same as Ergatta?
A. WaterRower manufactures both, but the Ergatta includes a touchscreen and gamified workouts, offering a more interactive experience.

Q. How does the Ergatta membership work?
A. The membership provides access to interactive workouts, live races, and gamified experiences for a monthly fee. It enhances the rowing experience by offering a variety of engaging and motivating features.

Q. Can WaterRower be upgraded with Ergatta features?
A. Yes, you can upgrade the WaterRower with a touchscreen and mounting arm from Ergatta, enjoying similar interactive and gamified features. This way, you get the simplicity of the WaterRower and the advanced features of Ergatta.

Jonathan Valdez, RDN, CDCES, CPT

Jonathan Valdez, RDN, CDCES, CPT is a New York City-based telehealth registered dietitian nutritionist and nutrition communications expert.
Average Customer Rating:0.0 / 5.0 
Customer Reviews

Rating Snapshot:

Excellent
0
Great
0
Average
0
Poor
0
Bad
0
Write a Review You can receive 50 rewards points by sharing your honest opinion of Write a Review
X

How helpful was it?

icon This article changed my life!
icon This article was informative.
icon I have a medical question.
X

How helpful was it?

icon This article changed my life!
Change
Your Rating
Note: Bodybuildingreviews isn't a healthcare provider. We can't respond to health questions or give you medical advice.
Your Privacyis important to us.
X

How helpful was it?

icon This article was informative.
Change
Your Rating
Note: Bodybuildingreviews isn't a healthcare provider. We can't respond to health questions or give you medical advice.
Your Privacyis important to us.
X
icon I have a medical question.
Change

We’re unable to offer personal health advice, but we’ve partnered with JustAnswer who offers on-demand doctors to answer your medical questions 24/7. Talk online now with a doctor and get fast 1-on-1 answers from the comfort of your couch.

just answer logo
ASK A DOCTOR NOW

If you’re facing a medical emergency, call your local emergency services immediately, or visit the nearest emergency room or urgent care center.

X

How can we improve it?

icon This article contains incorrect information.
icon This article doesn’t have the information I’m looking for.
icon I have a medical question.
X

How can we improve it?

icon This article contains incorrect information.
Change
Your Rating
Note: Bodybuildingreviews isn't a healthcare provider. We can't respond to health questions or give you medical advice.
Your Privacyis important to us.
X

How can we improve it?

icon This article doesn’t have the information I’m looking for.
Change
Your Rating
Note: Bodybuildingreviews isn't a healthcare provider. We can't respond to health questions or give you medical advice.
Your Privacyis important to us.
X
icon I have a medical question.
Change

We’re unable to offer personal health advice, but we’ve partnered with JustAnswer who offers on-demand doctors to answer your medical questions 24/7. Talk online now with a doctor and get fast 1-on-1 answers from the comfort of your couch.

just answer logo
ASK A DOCTOR NOW

If you’re facing a medical emergency, call your local emergency services immediately, or visit the nearest emergency room or urgent care center.

x

Have a Question? Please Tell Us What We Are Missing Here!

Find answers in product info, Q&As, reviews
Submit Your Privacyis important to us.